How to extend filter life, or reduce it, BIG TIME

70 replies [Last post]
Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

So I had my GC system installed last September. At that point, GC was telling installers to have return looped in before the veggie filter, not after. They went to this because they thought that running the return through the filter again would heat it up again.

Purging with this system did not back-flush the veggie filter.

Well, my filter life was always bad (1300 miles max). Most of you know I refine my WVO big time, so the filters were not clogging with particulate. Wax was building up such that even the normal heating of the filter did not melt it off, seems the constant loop of filtering the same fuel was doing it.

So last filter change I went and re-plumbed to the old style: return is after veggie filter. Purging results in filter back-flush. Fuel coming through filter is basically a trickle. What do you know, I'm at 1800 miles on this filter and no sign of clogging.

My Golf has a lift pump for the veggie, so between that and the IP, the fuel races around that loop big time. But, a friend of mine does not have the lift pump on his Beetle and was still getting short filter life. I guess the VW IP on the PD engines is pretty high volume by itself. He's switching his plumbing too.

As for purging, I know some of you have thought that it takes a load of diesel to purge through the filter and back to the tank. True enough. But if you have a HIH system, why bother purging all the way back? I've been purging for 30 seconds MAX with the new plumbing. All I really want to do is remove any WVO from the engine before switching to diesel so no WVO gets into the diesel tank. And, I want some back flow and a little diesel to get into the veggie filter so the wax doesn't build up.

One other cool thing about this setup is when changing filters, no need to pre-fill and possibly spill. Just put it in dry, then purge...look in veggie tank and wait until bubbles stop coming back to tank, then your know no more air in the system. I'll still probably fill every other filter with Diesel Purge or Power Service, unless my filters end up lasting a REALLY long time.

As for heat loss due to return not going through heated filter again, here are my thoughts: return fuel comes out of engine even hotter than when it went in. Also, the fuel that is being drawn from the filter is being done so at a trickle, so it is getting really hot before entering the loop. I think I will finally hook up some temp sensors to get real data. If I am losing heat, I'll go for a glow plug heater right before IP.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

JeffNLisa's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/07/2005

OK, that's good info.

Wax.

I've been getting about 5,000 miles per filter, but it's taken several cycles of that for me to notice that the power begins to go down slightly, LONG before end of filter life. I wonder if wax buildup is causing that. The Frybrid system uses no loop, so all the fuel the IP pulls and returns goes thru the filter constantly. But wouldn't adequate heat melt the wax right away each time you warm up?

Chase, if you will please, what aux pump did you put for your VO, and where exactly do you have it in your fuel line?

Thanks

Jeff

-------------------------
98 Jetta TDI, FRYBRID kit, 12/05.
======> 21,000 miles in first six greasy months-
91 F-250, 7.3, 5-Spd. Blending in the rear tank while working on a homebrewed conversion
97 Buick Park Avenue -- GONE!! There may be a Mercedes in Lisa's future!
86 Nissan Pathfinder -- MBZ 300 turbo motor in the works

86 Mustang SVO (Jeff's)
87 Mustang Convertible (Lisa's) with turbo motor from an 87 Turbo Coupe

And a SHAMELESS plug for my own business- www.prepaidlegal.com/go/lisaleon
Those who HAVE a Pre-Paid Legal membership are MUCH more likely to get good legal advice than those who DON'T.

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

So the Frybrid system has no loop? Where does the return fuel go when you are in veggie?

My lift pump is this little gold 10PSI unit that Daryl, my installer, put in. It is located at the front of the valve cover. It could be located at any point in the WVO system as long as it was before the IP. It seems that only the Beetle does not have an in-tank pump. The Golfs and Jettas do since the distance from IP to fuel tank is longer. I'm talking PD engines, not older TDIs.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

Bolete's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/01/2004

In the frybrid systen unused fuel is returned to the respective tank.

An earnest warning against looping your system to bypass the VO fitler: Debris can come loose through the injection system of your vehicle. The reason that Greasecar instructions have you return your fuel loop to the supply side of your filter is to protect your engine from debris. I would immediately replumb so that your VO passes through the VO filter on every pass. Even if it does mean that you have to change your filter more often, it's a lot cheaper than changing injectors, or an injection pump for that matter.

-------------------------
Ryan DeWald
Custom Vegetable Oil Fuel Conversions
www.BioCoupe.com

2001 VW Jetta TDI.
Greasecar kit
10,000 miles on SVO
averaging 200 miles per diesel gallon.

Get a V.O. temp gauge, it's worth every penny.

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Nope, that's not why. Justin only re-plumbed due to his concern with heat loss. In fact they may go back once they finish their own glow plug unit.

As for stuff coming out of your fuel system, kinda seems improbable, dontcha think? I mean, if something in your engine starts disintegrating, the IP is the least of your worries.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

2100 miles on my filter so far.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

Krazyman's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/12/2005

Your particular vehicle doesn't get the radiator fluid hot enough to work with the standard gc setup. You did what you had to do. Hopefully your regular diesel loop goes back thru the filter tho, since you need it to catch particles (such as metal bits from the ip) that could otherwise clog your injectors.

-------------------------
Freedom begins between the ears.
-Edward Abbey

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

What about adding one of those small fuel filters with cleanable 100 micron metal element, right before the IP?

I think there are also clear versions of this. If anyone has any info, let me know.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

I drove a whole lot in the pat 48 hours, 2500 miles now. Also, these 2500 are almost totally on grease as the warm temps mean fast warm-up time. Long trips too.

So I'm still looking for input on one of those little, clear, fuel filters with the plastic or metal elements. They come in 40 micron and 100 micron. I worry the plastic might not be able to handle the hot oil?

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

GETFRYD's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/20/2005

What about particulates below 40 micron?

When I installed my kit last August I called GC about the plumbing. They told me to plumb the return loop tee before the filter because of the risk that any particulate from the injection system should be filtered out before returning. I think you are posing an unnecessary risk to your IP.

-------------------------
2001 VW Golf TDI
GreasedGolf
Converted 9/1/05 @ 46,200 miles with standard Greasecar kit
Added vegtherm 11/1/05
Currently (2/25/06) 15k greasy miles
125 mile per day commuter

TDIguy's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/07/2004

Ok maybe i am missing something here but wouldnt i have much bigger problems if metal bits are being worn out of my ip or the engine? Metal bits indicares something being worn awey that can only happen for so long before there is a very seriouse problem.

-------------------------
01 vw jetta TDI : RC II : VR6 Clutch
Vag-Com tool at home
Running on Veg since summer 04 still learning new tricks.
11mm IP + lift pump = POWER
Another good veg site
http://fryertofuel.hypermart.net/store/page6.html

Donniej's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/07/2005

There is always wear in a mechanical device, wear = metal debris. The debris that is falling out of your IP may be microscopic but it would be ideal to filter it out.

PS. You might consider using a "primary filter" for the Mercedes. They have a fine mesh screen in a clear plastic housing. They're only ~$4 and you can buy them at Pep Boys or similar.

-------------------------
Her
"Do I smell McDonalds?"
Me
"No, that's my Bimmer"...
Her
"Will it make me fat?"
Me
"You're already fat"

Krazyman's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/12/2005

Glad to see I'm not the only return loop believer. If you want, you could even do a controlled flow return (add a valve, about half open), instead of eliminating it altogether.

-------------------------
Freedom begins between the ears.
-Edward Abbey

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

I'm trying to envision a system which has the return going through the filter, but when purging it purges the filter. I think if this were possible, filter life would be extended a good deal and there would still be the safety of return filtration.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

GETFRYD's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/20/2005

It's simple, and I suggested this to greasecar back in September. Add a 3rd solenoid.

NO = Normally Open
NC = Normally Closed
COM = Common

Supply solenoid (A)
NO: Diesel Supply
NC: Vegoil Supply
COM: to the IP

Return Soilenoid (B)
COM: from the IP
NO: Diesel Return
NC: Vegoil/Purge Return

Purge Solenoid (C)
COM: Vegoil/ Return
NO: Running Loop (tee on inlet side of filter)
NC: Filter Purge (tee on outlet side of filter)

When running in diesel mode (all valves have no power), the return is directed by valve B to the tank.

When running in vegoil mode (valves A & B have power) the return is directed to the loop tee'd before the filter.

When purging (Valves B and C have power) the return is directed to the purge tee after the filter (forcing a backflush to the vegoil tank).

To connect electrically, just wire valve C to the pourge side of your 3-way switch (Valve B is already wired to the purge side as well as the vegoil side).

BTW, at the time I suggested this to them, Greasecar added that they have moved away from the idea of purging (backflushing) the filter as it causes stresses on the filter element that it was not designed for. They saw more than one filter element fail due to this.

-------------------------
2001 VW Golf TDI
GreasedGolf
Converted 9/1/05 @ 46,200 miles with standard Greasecar kit
Added vegtherm 11/1/05
Currently (2/25/06) 15k greasy miles
125 mile per day commuter

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Cool! I knew a third solenoid would be needed but I just couldn't work out the rest.

As for the filter backflush thing. Daryl (the main GC installer) said it happened to one person. This guy kept using the purge to flush the filter after it started clogging, in the hopes of extending its life even further. So after pulsing it for a while, the filter totally exploded. My reaction was...DUH!

I will contact Daryl about possibly implementing the third solenoid.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

ronmcor's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/16/2005

I did my powerstroke like that but without a 3rd solenoid. Just use a check valve to prevent v/o from bypassing the filter when running v/o and tie the return in before and after the filter. You could also prevent the filter from backflushing by either using one with an integrated check valve or adding one just before the input side.

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

I can't quite envision your system. So when running grease, your return goes through the filter, but when purging you are able to back-flush the filter?

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

ronmcor's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/16/2005

no, not at all. My goal was to prevent v/o from constantly cycling through the filter during operation on v/o to extend filter life, and it did just that. The problem with looping after the filter was it would backwash the filter and all the associated "wax and crap" back to the tank during purge without some mods. The return was tied in between the filter and the pump and the filter and the tank both, with a check valve installed to prevent v/o from going around the filter while in v/o mode and another one to prevent v/o from backwashing the filter to the tank during the purge. (actually on the Davco I use it has a built in check valve). The only v/o to travel through the filter is what is actually used. The problem mentioned above with v/o possibly building up on the injector and breaking free (which is a good argument against it) is moot in the PSD as the fuel rail is dead headed anyway and if it were to happen it would happen regardless of how the return is plumbed.

ourwebstop's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

You know... the earlier Greasecar systems (like mine) have the return loop back to before filter, and they purge the filter. The old 6-port valve paired with a 3-port purge valve does exactly that.

I'm not sure what that has to do with filter-life, but I'm get 10,000 - 15,000 miles out of my filters.

-------------------------
Brian
vw.ourwebstop.com

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

3200 miles so far.

Almost all grease as summer is here and I've been doing some long trips.

To go from 1000 miles at most to over 3000 (and a suspicion it will go MUCH longer) means the system has to be reworked on Greasecar's end. Not sure exactly how, since I agree in theory that the return should also be filtered to some extent.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

ronmcor's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/16/2005

Chase, so you are not presently running your return through the filter, right? and you are getting much longer filter life? I was in the same boat and am on my first filter plumbed this way, I am already way ahead of my previous intervals and am happy to hear youre doing 3K already. Please keep me posted. ron

BrianMiller's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/11/2006

i didnt read all this but. my first truck was set up the greasel way. and when i went down there the first thing Charlie said was to add a small filter to the looped return line or after 30,000 miles you will have problems. and he was correct. i added a small filter and about 20,000 miles it was clogged. now all i do is return lines to the tanks.

-------------------------
I use to be ForrestGump..My Forum, My Web,My BLOG,

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Yep, my system is now plumbed so the return is after the filter.

Brian, what kind of small filter did you use?

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Bump.

Brian, what kind of small filter did you use?

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Just hit 5000 miles on this filter since the re-plumbing job. Again, almost all WVO as it is so warm out and I've still been doing a lot of longer trips.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

ronmcor's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/16/2005

thanks for the update Chase.

JeffNLisa's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/07/2005

Bump

Brian, I also wonder please, what small filter did you use?

Jeff

scuba1968girl's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/19/2005

Hi Guys,

I have been having to change my veggie filter way too often also. It seems like every 500 miles or so. This last time I changed it, and it seemed to be clogged up, I would just switch back to diesel for a few minutes and then switch back over to veggie and it would work for a few miles or until I hit a hill. I would then have to switch back to diesel until I got to the top of the hill or a few miles and then back to veggie. What is weird is that the veggie filter seems to work fine when it is working for those few minutes. I have to do this constantly.

What do you think the problem is?

At first I thought it was my grease, not filtered enough (only one filtering), but then I thought it might be small pieces of solid grease that haven't melted yet. I also thought maybe it could be trapped air in my system?

If it's air, how can I go about getting the air out? What can I do so solve my problem????

Alicia

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

If your return is looped back in before the veggie filter like mine originally was, this is typical. When the filter starts clogging, if you run on diesel for a little bit the filter clears up a bit. This is because the filter is being pressurized as it clogs. When you alleviate the pressure, some of the oil purges back into the tank due to the pressure (letting air out of a balloon).

Like you noticed, this only works for a few minutes or so.

I spoke with Daryl Beck, GC's main installer. He's been doing this, and building race cars for years. His opinion is that looping in after the veggie filter is the way to go. I confirmed that GC only changed this because they think the return fuel should be re-heated in the filter. He feels that the possibility of particles coming off the IP and then recirculating without being filtered is nothing important. Reason is, if particles are coming off your IP, its gonna die anyway. There are no other moving parts in the system, so no other wear points.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

scuba1968girl's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/19/2005

Could air in the lines also be a reason for the loss of power on veggie and then loop back around after I switch back to veggie? How can I purge air from my veggie line if there is? And, what is a check valve?

Alicia

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

I don't think so as you said you get 500 miles on veggie before the symptoms start. If it was air, the problem would be there all the time I assume.

Well, one perfect way to purge air from the veggie end is to re-plumb with the return coming in after the veggie filter. Every time you purge you back flush the entire system, filter and all. Great when changing filters as you don't have to prefill the thing and spill all over. Just screw it on, start the car on purge, look inside your veggie tank for the bubbles to stop. When they do, you're good to go.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

ronmcor's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/16/2005

Quote:
Originally posted by: scuba1968girl
Could air in the lines also be a reason for the loss of power on veggie and then loop back around after I switch back to veggie? How can I purge air from my veggie line if there is? And, what is a check valve?

Alicia
scuba1968girl, a check valve is usually a spring loaded valve, sometimes just a swing, that only allows fluid or air to travel in one direction.

scuba1968girl's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/19/2005

.

scuba1968girl's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/19/2005

Quote:
Originally posted by: Chase
So I had my GC system installed last September. At that point, GC was telling installers to have return looped in before the veggie filter, not after. They went to this because they thought that running the return through the filter again would heat it up again.

Purging with this system did not back-flush the veggie filter.

Well, my filter life was always bad (1300 miles max). Most of you know I refine my WVO big time, so the filters were not clogging with particulate. Wax was building up such that even the normal heating of the filter did not melt it off, seems the constant loop of filtering the same fuel was doing it.

So last filter change I went and re-plumbed to the old style: return is after veggie filter. Purging results in filter back-flush. Fuel coming through filter is basically a trickle. What do you know, I'm at 1800 miles on this filter and no sign of clogging.

My Golf has a lift pump for the veggie, so between that and the IP, the fuel races around that loop big time. But, a friend of mine does not have the lift pump on his Beetle and was still getting short filter life. I guess the VW IP on the PD engines is pretty high volume by itself. He's switching his plumbing too.

As for purging, I know some of you have thought that it takes a load of diesel to purge through the filter and back to the tank. True enough. But if you have a HIH system, why bother purging all the way back? I've been purging for 30 seconds MAX with the new plumbing. All I really want to do is remove any WVO from the engine before switching to diesel so no WVO gets into the diesel tank. And, I want some back flow and a little diesel to get into the veggie filter so the wax doesn't build up.

One other cool thing about this setup is when changing filters, no need to pre-fill and possibly spill. Just put it in dry, then purge...look in veggie tank and wait until bubbles stop coming back to tank, then your know no more air in the system. I'll still probably fill every other filter with Diesel Purge or Power Service, unless my filters end up lasting a REALLY long time.

As for heat loss due to return not going through heated filter again, here are my thoughts: return fuel comes out of engine even hotter than when it went in. Also, the fuel that is being drawn from the filter is being done so at a trickle, so it is getting really hot before entering the loop. I think I will finally hook up some temp sensors to get real data. If I am losing heat, I'll go for a glow plug heater right before IP.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI
Hi Chase,

I'm finally getting around to fixing my short filter life. I've got my GreaseCar installation booklet in front of me (purchased kit last fall) and the veggie return line is coming from solenoid B to before the veggie filter. Ok, now are you talking about moving the veggie return line to after the veggie filter and before the solenoid A?? I just want to make sure that I have it right before I make the modification. If I do this modification, should I put an in-line prefilter after my return line before the solenoid A???

I'm on a new veggie filter @ 270 miles and it's clogging already. Is it possible that I have bacteria in my filter that could be causing it to clog?

Alicia

MarkP's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/08/2005

I have been looping after the filter also (on certain vehicles), it eliminates alot of vacuum and greatly increases filter life (and perhaps pump life?). True that now the oil is not being reheated, but insulated lines and short loop help this problem. Also true that there may be a risk of metalic contamination, but if this was a concern for OEM, would they use a return filter instead of sending it back to tank?
I am very interested in what people have to say on the metallic contamination issue!

I am still plumbing PD's with return to inlet since they do fine this way and sending the high return flow backwards through filter concerns me. I have plumbed a few P/strokes with loop ahead of filter and they have been working great (believe it or not, they flow less return then a PD!). I installed Vac, psi and temp test gauges throughout to determine just what was happening plumbing this way, seems like the way to go for the GC kit. Returning back to tank or back into filter definately creates more vacuum, seems that if not returning to tank, you might as well take full advantage of a looped system with returning ahead of filter. One thing to remember when looping this way is that return lines need to be in good shape to take the additional psi they are subject to when flushing.

I am experimenting with a 2.5 PSI bypass check valve so that return psi backwards through filter can only get to 2.5 before dumping to inletside and back to tank. I would be much more comfortable looping this way if somthing like this was part of it.
The first car I plumbed this way was an MBZ, the owner was complaining about filter life (like many). He now has tripled his filter life since I changed it. Seems that MBZ's respond best to this and I also do not worry about hurting IP's on these cars.
There are some underhood pics on Greasecar profiles page of cars I plumbed this way, with line insulation (one is a silver 03 Jetta wagon).

-------------------------
MarkP

scuba1968girl's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/19/2005

Anyone else answer my question about changing the return line to after the veggie filter and before the solenoid A or another place?

Alicia

forgetaboutit's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/21/2006

I've done about 6k grease miles and only had to change my filter1x. Probably due to the fact that I prefilter to 1 micron and dewater.

-------------------------
Please make sure you have enough life insurance. Ask me!

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Not sure on the A/B thing, but I simply moved the return from original spot: 8 inches before veggie filter and about 6 inches from where pex comes out of splitter block

to new spot: about 8 inches after veggie filter but before first solenoid.

So there is still a loop, but it only sips fuel from the filter as the engine burns it. Purging means backflushing filter. Nice, since the filter gets filled with petrodiesel.

I'm at about 7500 miles on my filter now. Much better than 1000!

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

scuba1968girl's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/19/2005

Thanks Chase,

I'll hopefully be able to get to it on Tuesday. I'll let you know what my results are.

Alicia

JeffNLisa's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/07/2005

My Frybrid system by design returns to tank, not to loop. The most I have gotten is about 6,000 miles from one filter, I've gotten over 5,000 on two. But I have also burned thru some in 500 miles, and could not figure out why.

What I've done just to alleviate stress on the IP is loop the return to come in AFTER the filter (and before the final HE). Purging backflushes the filter in this setup. I am not aware of much benefit to this purge, but the filter I have reportedly tolerates it, and so it doesn't hurt anything.

I tend to trust what Brian said and what he reports Charlie said. I also want a way to quickly and esily handle an air bubble in the loop if I got one (although I've driven 3,000 miles this way and never gotten one). So what I did is order a 3rd solenoid valve and put that in the return on the VO side coming off the return valve. For the diesel side, the only choice is back to diesel tank. For the VO side, it goes thru this 3rd valve, and then either returns to loop or returns to tank. What I have been doing is switching it to return to tank for a mile or two about every 3-400 miles, or about once each tank fillup. This way, any perticles that might get thru the filter and get trapped ciculating in the loop (or any metal particles that erode off the injectors or anywhere else) have a few minutes to flush to the tank, where if they get picked up in the fuel pickup will get stopped by the filter anyway.

This way I have the benefit of much less vacuum suction in normal operation, right up until end of filter life.

I plan to install a helper pump in the near future, and see if by the time the filter begins to clog, if I flip on the pump, if it gets me a little longer, as I expect to be the case.

Will report on that if I do it . . .

Jeff

-------------------------
98 Jetta TDI, Frybrid kit, Installation thread here. 27,000 miles on VO as of 9/1/06
91 F-250, 7.3, 5-Spd. Blending in the rear tank while working on a homebrewed conversion. 8,000 miles on VO as of 9/1/06

Installing VO conversion kits in Southern California, e-mail me. My e-mail is in my profile.

born2crazy's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/25/2004

If you did get air in the loop, wouldn't it just sputter a little until all the air had been pushed through the injectors?

And wouldn't the same be true for any metal particles (as long as they are small enough to make it through the injectors)?

If this is true, then air/particles in the loop would not be trapped for a long period of time like motor oil in a crank case, but would only have a very short time to cause wear before passing out the exhaust pipe.

I thought about plumbing the loop back after the filter about a year ago, but am still returning vo to the vo tank just because I'm not 100% confident in my thinking.

HECK, as far as that goes, you could plumb the return back just between the feeding solenoid and the IP. Then you would only need ONE SOLENOID TO OPERATE THE WHOLE GREASECAR SYSTEM!!!

It makes sense to me, but my only real reservation is... Why didn't they just do it that way from the factory??? You know, why didn't they just plumb the return from the IP right back into the IP intake????......That's the reason I'm still scared to do it.

Comments please, because I am tired of replacing filters, and just might do it yet......

-------------------------
How can I color inside the lines when I'm thinking outside the box!!??

born2crazy's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/25/2004

Plumbing the return in right before the intake (as opposed to returning to respective tank) would also cut down on the oil's resistance to flow to the IP as the total volume of oil being pulled the whole length of the fuel line whould be cut waaay down.

Of course if I did plumb right before the intake and after the feeding solenoid, I'd use one of those small inline filters.

If you did do it this way, and only used the one solenoid for the whole system, you would eliminate the possibility of sending diesel to VO tank or VO to D tank if one solenoid were to fail.

There would also never be any need to purge anything either, if your (only) solenoid is close to your spinon fuel filter or there is some heat going all the way to the inlet port.... I just recently re-aligned my fuel line going from spinon to intake solenoid just on top of a coolant hose, zip tied it good, and wrapped it with a piece of pipe insulation.

Tell me what you think guys/gals because I'm really wanting to try it but am afraid I'm overlooking some reason why it wouldn't work...

-------------------------
How can I color inside the lines when I'm thinking outside the box!!??

born2crazy's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/25/2004

What the Heck????

The thread just posted my last reply ahead of the previous one!!!

As you're scrolling down, the second reply from me is actually the first one I submitted.

????

-------------------------
How can I color inside the lines when I'm thinking outside the box!!??

born2crazy's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/25/2004

It did it again!!!

Must be something new I didn't know about...

-------------------------
How can I color inside the lines when I'm thinking outside the box!!??

DK
DK's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/23/2005

Quote:
Originally posted by: JeffNLisa

My Frybrid system by design returns to tank, not to loop. The most I have gotten is about 6,000 miles from one filter, I've gotten over 5,000 on two. But I have also burned thru some in 500 miles, and could not figure out why.

What I've done just to alleviate stress on the IP is loop the return to come in AFTER the filter (and before the final HE). Purging backflushes the filter in this setup. I am not aware of much benefit to this purge, but the filter I have reportedly tolerates it, and so it doesn't hurt anything.

I tend to trust what Brian said and what he reports Charlie said. I also want a way to quickly and esily handle an air bubble in the loop if I got one (although I've driven 3,000 miles this way and never gotten one). So what I did is order a 3rd solenoid valve and put that in the return on the VO side coming off the return valve. For the diesel side, the only choice is back to diesel tank. For the VO side, it goes thru this 3rd valve, and then either returns to loop or returns to tank. What I have been doing is switching it to return to tank for a mile or two about every 3-400 miles, or about once each tank fillup. This way, any perticles that might get thru the filter and get trapped ciculating in the loop (or any metal particles that erode off the injectors or anywhere else) have a few minutes to flush to the tank, where if they get picked up in the fuel pickup will get stopped by the filter anyway.

This way I have the benefit of much less vacuum suction in normal operation, right up until end of filter life.

I plan to install a helper pump in the near future, and see if by the time the filter begins to clog, if I flip on the pump, if it gets me a little longer, as I expect to be the case.

Will report on that if I do it . . .

Jeff

-------------------------
98 Jetta TDI, Frybrid kit, Installation thread here. 27,000 miles on VO as of 9/1/06
91 F-250, 7.3, 5-Spd. Blending in the rear tank while working on a homebrewed conversion. 8,000 miles on VO as of 9/1/06

Installing VO conversion kits in Southern California, e-mail me. My e-mail is in my profile.

Could you send me the info on a lift pump if you get one? I am having the same terrible filter life lately. I do think that it is wax also.

DK

-------------------------
300sd 253,000 The gold 'Benz
300sd 390,000 The Red Beast

born2crazy's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/25/2004

I think I'm going to go ahead and plumb a small inline "insurance filter" between my incoming solenoid and the lift pump. Then I'm planning to run a line from the VO port of the return solenoid back to just before the "insurance filter".

This will slighty increase my shutdown time (currently 10 sec at idle) but will provide added protection to my IP by double filtering ALL incoming fuel and will offer much less resistance to flow when running veg (prolonging spinon filter life.)

Anybody see a problem with the idea?

-------------------------
How can I color inside the lines when I'm thinking outside the box!!??

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

OK, so exactly 9800 miles until the filter finally showed some restriction at high RPMs. I think I'll stay with this setup.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

sail59115 (not verified)
sail59115's picture

Do any of you guys have vacuum gauge readings on these different configurations?

-------------------------
2003 Golf, 2004 Jetta Wagon w/ standard Greasecar kits.

Chase's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/27/2004

Nope. Just flooring it, uphill, until redline. If it stutters, I change the filter. Didn't stutter until 9800 miles.

I may install a vac gauge soon as I like fiddling with data whenever I can.

-------------------------
2005 VW Golf PD-TDI

JeffNLisa's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/07/2005

Quote:
Originally posted by: DK
Could you send me the info on a lift pump if you get one? I am having the same terrible filter life lately. I do think that it is wax also.

DK

-------------------------
300sd 253,000 The gold 'Benz
300sd 390,000 The Red Beast

In the 300SDs we have done, we have used AirTex pumps, about 8 psi, or Master pumps, 5.5-9 psi. The Master ones are avaiable at AutoZone, and although the longest time I am aware of on one is about 6 months, I've never heard of a failure, and I know two people who have been installing them for a lot longer than 6 months. And for the $40-50 they cost, if they had to be replaced every 6 months, that would really be acceptable.

The ones where we have used that pump have non-looped returns. If you have a looped return, and you purge thru the supply line, you can't put the pump before the loop; you have to include it in the loop.

I have not put a pump in my Jetta, becasue I am now over 5,000 miles on my current filter, with nary a sign of any clogging.

I cleaned my tank. If polymerization was the cause of the short filter life (which I do not know) then cleaning it was the solution. I alos think that if the tank had to be cleaned once a year, that would also be acceptable.

But a lot of people don't clean their tanks out, even way after a year. So I don't know.

Jeff

-------------------------
98 Jetta TDI, Frybrid kit, Installation thread here. 27,000 miles on VO as of 9/1/06
91 F-250, 7.3, 5-Spd. Blending in the rear tank while working on a homebrewed conversion. 8,000 miles on VO as of 9/1/06

Installing VO conversion kits in Southern California, e-mail me. My e-mail is in my profile.